UMHS Online Writing Lab
Comparison Contrast Essay Checklist Rubric
5=Excellent 4=Highly Competent 3=Competent 2=Inadequate Response 1=Numerous Errors
Directions:
Score each area on a scale of 1-5
Ideas and Content __________
compares and contrasts subjects clearly
demonstrates a clear sense of purpose by use of the thesis statement
ideas are fully developed
opens with an attention-getting introduction
ends with an effective conclusion
Sentence Fluency __________
includes transitional words and phrases to show relationships
among ideas and maintain coherence within and between paragraphs
uses a variety of sentence structures
sentences are clear and avoid clutter
Organization __________
correctly uses a multiple paragraph format
organizes ideas logically, using either Block or Point by Point format
devotes one paragraph to each main idea
Conventions __________
contains no more than two or three minor errors in grammar and usage
contains no more than two or three minor errors in capitalization and punctuation
words are spelled correctly
18-20 = A
14-16 = B
11-13 = C
8-10 = D
7 and below = F
Total ______ Comments: